Yarra Yering Dry Red No.1 2009 and other complaints

I was disappointed by Yarra Yering's 2009 "Dry Red No. 1" cabernet (and their cellar door - see below).  Good blackcurrant aromas drifted out of the glass.  But the palate seemed short, with evident acidity and, to my palate, a touch of a smoked meat character.  This latter character made me wonder whether the vintage may have been affected, albeit minutely at this stage, by the tragic 2009 Yarra Valley bushfires.  Yeringberg up the road of course have declassified their 2009 cabernet and are selling it for $15, with the de Purys recommending early consumption in case the smoke taint worsens.  There is a touch of smoke taint on the palate in the 09 Yeringberg, but frankly it is pretty mild at this point.

In Yarra Yering's case, at $82 a bottle for their 09, and down the road, it seemed worth a discussion.  Such discussion unfortunately though was not going to come from our cellar door host.  In between pouring thimble sized servings during the paid tasting into lovely Riedel glasses (tough times chez Yarra Yering?) and curtly telling my unsuspecting friend that "no, you've already tasted the Agincourt" (he hadn't - and, um, what Sir, if he had?), his comment to me regarding a smoky character was "No, you are the first person to say that.  You must be wrong".  And maybe I am wrong - that certainly does happen!  It could have been another character from that tragic, hot, scorching and bushfire ridden season.  But it was an honest question.  And surely it's not a surprising one given the sheer scale of the bushfires in 2009?  Whatever the cause, the wine simply wasn't otherwise what I expected and as regular readers would know, to date, I've been a strong supporter of Yarra Yering's cabernets, describing them as among, if not, the best in the Yarra Valley.  One to try again in a few years time.  I hope I am wrong.  84 points for now (6.9/10)

Abv: not recorded
Price: $82
Website: http://www.yarrayering.com

you might also like

Yarra Valley

3 comments:

  1. I avoid 09 Yarra reds generally, and its suprising to see that they have released their cabernet to be frank. The Yeringberg approach would seem far more sensible.
    As for the cellar door experience, that is terrible, but not the first time I've heard of such experiences with Yarra Yering.
    All of which is a shame, because, as you say, their wines can be superb.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Likewise love Yarra Yering, in particular the Dry Red No.1, but I've never been to the cellar door, so sad to hear this honest tale Sean.

    Cheers,
    Chris P

    ReplyDelete
  3. Thanks Gents for your thoughts. And Red this was news to me that others have had similar experiences. I agree with avoiding the 09 YV reds. Hell, it was so hot in February 09 here in Melbourne that we saw possums fleeing across the street in broad daylight!

    Cheers
    Sean

    ReplyDelete

To subscribe to Grape Observer please click here.



About

Grapeobserver.com is an independent wine review and journal. For further information about your author, please click here. To subscribe to Grape Observer you can click here.